Picking a major is a bet on the future, and some bets pay off slower than others. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York tracks unemployment, underemployment, and wages for 73 college majors, and its February 2026 update, built on 2024 Census data, shows some clear patterns.
"Useless" is headline talk, not a verdict. These are fields where recent graduates are more likely to be out of work, stuck in jobs that don't need a degree, or earning less than the typical grad, compared with the all-major averages in the same dataset.
None of that means employers will reject every graduate in 2027, and it doesn't erase the value of the education itself.
If you're weighing a major, switching careers, or helping a grandkid plan for college, it helps to know where the data shows friction and what graduates do to work around it, including picking up extra credentials or finding an online side hustle while building experience.
Fine arts
Painting or sculpting for a living sounds romantic until the bills arrive. According to the New York Fed's February 2026 release of 2024 data, fine arts majors had a 7.7% unemployment rate, the third-highest of the 73 majors tracked, behind anthropology and computer engineering.
Underemployment is the bigger issue: 58.9% of fine arts grads worked in jobs that typically don't require a degree, versus 39.4% across all majors. Early-career pay runs about $45,000 a year, compared with $58,000 overall, though mid-career median pay rises to $72,000.
Graduates who build a strong portfolio and move into design, education, or arts administration tend to do better than the raw averages suggest.
Anthropology
Digging through the past doesn't always translate into an easy job hunt. Anthropology posted the highest unemployment rate of any of the 73 majors the New York Fed tracks, at 7.9% for recent grads, nearly double the 4.2% all-majors average, based on 2024 data.
Underemployment sits at 55.3%, compared with 39.4% overall. Early-career pay is $45,000, rising to $65,000 mid-career, versus $58,000 and $87,000 across all majors. The field's unemployment rate has also climbed, from 6.5% in 2021 to 7.9% in the latest data.
Graduates often land in cultural resource management, museums, government archaeology work, market research, or UX design, frequently after a certificate or master's degree.
Performing arts
Chasing a stage career means accepting an uneven paycheck early on. Recent performing arts graduates had a 7% unemployment rate in the New York Fed's latest data, among the highest of the 73 majors tracked, well above the roughly 4.2% rate for recent grads overall.
Underemployment hit 63.9%, meaning roughly two-thirds of recent grads worked in jobs that don't require a bachelor's degree. Early-career median pay is $44,000, versus $58,000 overall, and mid-career pay reaches only about $75,000.
Researchers note that underemployed grads in this field still tend to hold skilled, decently paid jobs. Building credits through regional theater, teaching, or arts administration can help graduates piece together steadier income early on.
Liberal arts and general studies
A broad liberal arts education teaches you to think, but it doesn't always point to one job title. In the New York Fed's 2024 data, liberal arts had a 54.6% underemployment rate, placing it among the ten majors above 50%, well above the 39.4% rate across all recent grads.
Unemployment tells a different story: Liberal arts didn't make the list of majors with the highest unemployment rates, which topped out with anthropology at 7.9%. Most liberal arts grads do find work, often just not work that requires their specific degree.
The tradeoff isn't joblessness. It's a higher chance of landing in a job that doesn't require the degree, which pairing the major with an internship, a technical minor, or a professional certificate can help offset.
Film, video and photographic arts
Dreaming of a career behind the camera comes with real risk of an early detour. Georgetown University's Center on Education and the Workforce found unemployment rates for early-career bachelor's degree holders ranging from 1.3% for operations logistics and e-commerce majors to 11% for film, video, and photographic arts majors.
That 11% rate is well above the 5.3% overall unemployment rate for 2021-23 grads in the same analysis. The New York Fed's own major table doesn't list this field separately, but its closest categories, fine arts and performing arts, show similarly elevated unemployment and underemployment.
Bureau of Labor Statistics data put the median wage for the broader fine and performing arts group at $54,000, compared with $73,000 across all fields in 2024. Arts graduates are also more likely to be self-employed or take longer to find their footing, which can inflate measured unemployment without meaning the degree has no payoff.
A demo reel, freelance credits, or an editing certification can help graduates stand out faster.
English language and literature
Loving to read and write doesn't guarantee a smooth jump to a paycheck. The New York Fed's 2024 data puts English majors' unemployment rate at 6.1% and underemployment at 48.5%, with early-career median pay of $48,000 climbing to $76,000 mid-career, a $28,000 jump.
The Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC) notes that less quantitative majors, including communications and sociology, tend to have higher underemployment than fields offering occupation-specific training. Nearly half of English majors, about 47%, go on to earn a graduate degree.
Common paths include teaching at the elementary, secondary, or postsecondary level, plus writing and editing roles. The same PPIC analysis found underemployment for English majors has notably decreased over time as graduates gain experience.
Sociology
Studying how people and society work doesn't always translate into a clear career ladder. Recent sociology graduates had a 52% underemployment rate, well above the 39.4% average across all majors, according to the New York Fed's 2024 data.
Early-career median pay is $49,900, below the $58,000 all-major median, and mid-career pay reaches $79,000, trailing the $87,000 overall figure. Sociology's 4.6% unemployment rate is close to the 4.2% all-major average, so the challenge here is underemployment and pay, not joblessness.
About 45% of sociology graduates go on to earn a graduate or professional degree, often moving into research, social services, or human resources roles that reward the added credential.
Philosophy and religious studies
Big questions about ethics and existence can lead to real careers, especially in law. Recent philosophy graduates had a 5.1% unemployment rate, modestly above the 4.2% all-major average, and a 47.1% underemployment rate, versus 39.4% overall, per the New York Fed's 2024 data.
Early-career median pay is $52,000, below the $58,000 all-major figure, though mid-career pay reaches $80,000. Related theology and religion majors had lower unemployment at 3.1% but higher underemployment at 47.5% and the lowest early-career pay among these fields, at $41,600.
Philosophy majors post strong LSAT scores and some of the best law school admission and enrollment rates of any major, and 57% of philosophy graduates hold a graduate degree, often explaining the apparent underemployment gap.
Leisure and hospitality
Hospitality jobs are plentiful, but the pay and job level often lag. The New York Fed's 2024 data shows a 58.1% underemployment rate for leisure and hospitality majors, among the highest of the 73 majors tracked, alongside a low 2.7% unemployment rate.
Early-career median pay is $45,000, roughly $13,000 below the $58,000 all-major median, and mid-career pay reaches $75,000. By comparison, nursing has the lowest underemployment rate in the dataset, at 12.8%, with early-career pay of $70,000.
The field's challenge shows up in underemployment and pay, not in finding a job at all, and certifications tied to hospitality management or event planning can help close the gap.
Communications
A communications degree opens doors, but not always to a role that uses it right away. The New York Fed's 2024 data puts the underemployment rate for communications grads at 53%, among the ten highest of all majors tracked, with unemployment around 3.9%.
Early-career median pay is $52,000, below the $58,000 all-major figure, but by mid-career, communications majors reach $88,000, slightly above the $87,000 all-major median. That catch-up suggests the early underemployment gap narrows with experience rather than reflecting a dead-end field.
Graduates who add skills in digital marketing, public relations, or content strategy tend to move past entry-level underemployment faster.
Early childhood education
Teaching the youngest students is meaningful work, but the pay often doesn't keep pace. Early childhood education tied for the 8th-highest unemployment rate among the 73 majors tracked, at 6.6%, according to the New York Fed's 2024 data.
That's a clear outlier within education itself: Special education majors had the lowest unemployment rate of any major, at 0.7%, followed by elementary and secondary education. Early childhood education also has the lowest mid-career median wage of any tracked major, at $52,000 a year.
New York Fed research notes that education majors, including early childhood education, tend to have below-average underemployment, meaning most graduates who find work are using their degree, just at modest pay. An added credential, such as a special education endorsement, can help with pay over time.
Bottom line
None of these majors are dead ends. The New York Fed's own researchers point out that many "underemployed" graduates hold skilled, reasonably paid jobs and move into better roles as they gain experience, and several of these fields show real wage growth from early to mid-career.
If you're choosing a major now, weighing a career change, or helping someone else plan, pair the degree with internships, certifications, or graduate study in the field's strongest niches, and keep your broader financial fitness steady while you build experience.
Add Us On Google