Combing thrift stores for resellable treasures or sorting through your childhood collection can be a great way to make extra money, especially if you have access to the types of vintage 1950s toys that catch collectors' eyes. But how do you sort the trash from the treasure? After all, not every item is valuable for its age alone: even 70-year-old toys can sell for a dime a dozen if they were mass-produced, out of the original box, or worn down after years of play.
In this article, we cover some valuable 1950s toys that have sold for remarkable prices in recent years. We'll explain signs that an old item is worth hanging onto or having evaluated — as well as when it's better to toss out or donate a toy with fond memories but limited value.
Download this gaming app that's paid out over $500 million
A company called Freecash has compiled all sorts of quick cash tasks from advertisers and market research companies. Freecash has paid out over $500 million to users since 2019, and has an "excellent" Trustpilot rating based on 300,000+ reviews.
Sign up here to see how much you could earn.
Matchbox ERF heavy lorry (series 20-A)
Estimated market value: $9,000
Before being purchased by Mattel, Matchbox cars were manufactured by the British toy company Lesney Products. Starting in 1953, the company sold small, die-cast versions of real cars in matchbox-sized boxes for literal pennies.
Matchbox cars were both popular and mass-produced, so not all models are inherently valuable, especially well-loved items that have rusted with time. But some extremely early models are rare enough to command serious money at market, including certain versions of the company's ERF heavy lorry, a WWII vehicle. Most versions of the toy were red, but a lime-green model once sold for $9,000.
DC Comics Showcase No. 22 (Sept. 1959)
Estimated market value: Up to $36,000
Strictly speaking, comics aren't toys, but they're definitely grouped under the category of children's entertainment. Selling for just $0.10 at first printing, the September 1959 edition of DC's Showcase comic marked Green Lantern's debut into the world of comic book superheroes.
A near-mint copy of the Hal Jordan Showcase (featuring the story "Menace of the Runaway Missile!") is valued at $36,000. If your copy has more wear and tear, you might still be able to sell for $3,600. Comic collections can command serious money these days, so if you think you have some valuable originals on hand, getting them graded by a certified collectibles group like CGC Comics could be a smart investment.
1951 Bowman Willie Mays #305
Estimated market value: Up to $20,000
If you grew up in a sports-loving family in the '50s, you probably spent at least as much time combing through your collectible baseball cards as you did playing with Matchbox cars. Willie Mays' rookie card shows one of the sport's greatest players holding his bat at the plate and ready to swing. A low-grade card (which typically has some mild wear and tear) can sell for around $3,000, but those in mint condition will net you closer to $20,000.
Stop overpaying when you shop online
Tired of chasing coupon codes and comparing prices across tabs? Try Capital One Shopping — a free browser extension that scours the internet for coupons and flags better prices while you shop.
Add it today and you could stop overpaying!1 <p>Capital One Shopping compensates us when you get the browser extension using the links we provided.</p>
Original Mr. Potato Head
Estimated market value: Up to $100
Mr. Potato Head originally came without the plastic body kids today are familiar with. Instead, the early toy was a real potato supplied not by the toy's manufacturer, Hasbro, but by the buyer themselves. Hasbro simply sold the pieces that kids could poke into a potato to give it a face — eyes, ears, nose, mustache, lips, and more.
Some of the first Mr. Potato Head accessories were made of felt. Others were made of plastic, which stood the test of time only a bit more reliably than the felt versions. In spite of their age and rarity, full sets are only valued at around $100, and most sell for less.
1952 Matchbox Aveling Barford road roller
Estimated market value: $100
Like the ERF heavy lorry, the Aveling Barford road roller was one of the first Matchbox cars sold in British shops. However, the model car — which had bright red wheels, a green body, and a driver sitting behind the wheel — was very popular, so most versions aren't worth much today. However, rarer models with slightly longer roofs can net up to $100, especially those in mint condition and still in the original matchbox-sized packaging.
1956 unopened Play-Doh
Estimated market value: Up to $150
The company Rainbow Crafts first manufactured the toy we now know as Play-Doh as a tool for cleaning wallpaper. But once kids got their hands on it, the cleaner's potential as a toy was clear, and the company started marketing it to kids in an off-white color only in 1956.
In spite of their impressive age, opened and used Play-Doh cans aren't worth much (if any) money, but unopened cans in fair condition can sell for anywhere from $20 to $150.
Bottom line
If you're pretty sure collectors would be interested in one of your vintage toys, do your research first to ensure you really can make money from home selling your childhood treasures. Look up recent sales on sites like eBay, comparing the seller's asking price to the final sales amount.
Pay close attention to how quality and condition impact real-world sales. If you'd rather sell in person than online, consider stopping by your local antique shops, pawn shops, thrift stores, or appraisers, and collect at least two quotes before making a final sales decision to make sure you're getting a fair market price.
More from FinanceBuzz:
- Things to cut when living on retirement (many people ignore #11).
- 14 moves seniors could benefit from but often forget about.
- Find out if you could pay less for car insurance in just a few clicks.
- Learn how to escape the paycheck-to-paycheck grind.
Add Us On Google