Retirement Retirement Planning

6 Times It’s Totally Okay To Ignore Dave Ramsey’s 8% Retirement Rule

The financial guru’s advice is controversial, and here are some reasons why.

planning budget together
Updated Oct. 26, 2024
Fact checked

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

If you are planning for retirement or simply trying to build savings, you're probably familiar with Dave Ramsey. The famous money guru is known for stirring debate with some of his suggestions.

Ramsey argues for withdrawing 8% from your retirement account each year to meet your expenses during your golden years. Here are six reasons why you might want to rethink following Ramsey’s advice.

Find Medicare plans with low or $0/month premium
Compare Medicare Advantage plans side-by-side to find what’s right for you
— Select a state below —

What is Dave Ramsey's 8% retirement rule?

sommart/Adobe percentage and question mark

Ramsey suggests that retirees invest all their assets in equities before annually withdrawing 8% of the portfolio’s starting value, with adjustments each year for inflation.

This is much higher than the 4% or even 3% that many other experts recommend as prudent.

Part of Ramsey’s strategy is based on the stock market's past performance, which historically has generated returns of around 10% annually. Ramsey believes an 8% annual withdrawal is sustainable if you can generate returns that match that average.

However, if you want to maximize your retirement savings, here are some reasons you might want to hesitate before following Ramsey’s advice.

Your nest egg is probably too small

wutzkoh/Adobe analyzing expenses

It’s apparent that you are going to need a large nest egg to follow this 8% suggested plan. That simply isn’t a reality for a lot of retirees.

The median retirement savings for all Americans is just $87,000, according to the most recent numbers from the Federal Reserve. That won’t get you very far in retirement no matter what withdrawal rate you choose.

The stock market might not do as well as Ramsey thinks

Rido/Adobe Stock market crash

The success of Ramsey’s 8% strategy relies heavily on the stock market achieving an average annual return of 10%. Historically, that is indeed about how well the stock market has performed.

But there is no guarantee of such success in the future.

In addition, stocks can perform poorly for long periods. If you are unlucky and end up withdrawing money as the market is falling, you could significantly erode your savings quickly. This is a phenomenon known as "sequence of return risk."

Earn $200 cash rewards bonus with this incredible card

There's a credit card that's making waves with its amazing bonus and benefits. The Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card(Rates and fees) has no annual fee and you can earn $200 after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months.

The Active Cash Card puts cash back into your wallet. Cardholders can earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases — easy! That's one of the best cash rewards options available.

This card also offers an intro APR of 0% for 12 months from account opening on purchases and qualifying balance transfers (then 19.74%, 24.74%, or 29.74% Variable). Which is great for someone who wants a break from high interest rates, while still earning rewards.

The best part? There's no annual fee.

Click here to apply now.

You might have to take too much risk to meet your goal

agenturfotografin/Adobe senior woman checking her investment

Many experts argue that it is risky to keep 100% of your portfolio in equities during retirement.

Instead, they recommend diversifying your investments and keeping some money in safer instruments, such as bonds and even savings accounts.

If you have 100% of your money in stocks during retirement and the market crashes badly, you might not have enough time to wait for stocks to fully bounce back.

You might have to sell assets in a downturn to meet the 8% goal

Bird Photographer TH/Adobe crisis chart

It’s one thing to pull 8% from your account in a year when stocks are soaring, but it’s something else entirely to withdraw from accounts that are cratering in a bear market.

If your investments have declined significantly, selling them to bring in income makes some of your losses permanent. This can make your nest egg dwindle quickly.

You might have to take Social Security early

Lane Erickson/Adobe Social Security Statement for Retirement Planning

If stock market returns lag what you expected and your savings start to dry up, you might be forced to file for Social Security earlier than you expected.

Filing for Social Security early means your monthly benefit will be permanently lower than if you had waited until later in life. Those who wait until age 70 to file get the biggest monthly checks.

You might run out of money

BullRun/Adobe pointing at a laptop screen

The bottom line is that withdrawing 8% of your portfolio year in and year out puts you at a serious risk of running out of money if the stock market does not perform as well as you had hoped.

If that happens, you might be forced to return to working again to generate income.

What other experts suggest instead

pla2na/Adobe percent sign moving down

Ramsey’s advice goes against the more popular 4% rule.

This rule states that you can significantly lower the risk of running out of money by safely withdrawing an amount equal to 4% of your savings during the year you retire and then adjusting for inflation each year over a period of about 30 years.

Some experts even suggest a 3% rule just to be extra safe. If you want to eliminate some money stress, withdrawing 4% or 3% gives you a bigger margin of safety than withdrawing 8%.

Bottom line

lashkhidzetim/Adobe glasses on the glass table

As you prepare for retirement, consider whether you should follow Ramsey’s advice to use the 8% rule.

If you have a large nest egg and the stock market performs well, things might work out fine. But you are taking on an extra level of risk by withdrawing so much from your accounts each year.

Lucrative, Flat-Rate Cash Rewards

5.0
info

Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card

Current Offer

$200 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months

Annual Fee

$0

Rewards Rate

Earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases

Benefits and Drawbacks
Card Details