Saving & Spending Budgeting & Expenses

Are Peeps the Most Hated Easter Candy?

FinanceBuzz wanted to discover America's favorite feelings about Peeps and other Easter candies.

Marshmallow Peeps candies on the shelf
Updated April 1, 2025
Fact checked

Easter baskets across the nation will be filled with chocolates, jelly beans, and (sometimes) beloved marshmallow candies in just a few weeks. Americans have historically spent billions on Easter candy, and this year isn't expected to be any different.

For almost 70 years, Peeps marshmallow candies — those instantly recognizable chicks and bunnies covered in sparkly sugar — have made their way into Easter baskets. Candy company Just Born makes two billion Peeps each year at their Pennsylvania headquarters in preparation for Easter – that's over five million a day.

But these marshmallow candies are as divisive as they are ubiquitous.

FinanceBuzz asked 1,000 U.S. adults to tell us their feelings about Peeps, rank their favorite Peeps flavors, and share what candies they hope make it into their Easter basket this year.

Key findings

  • Americans are divided on Peeps marshmallow candies: 25% love them, while 16% hate them.
  • Peeps don't rank among the top three favorite Easter candies — that honor goes to Reese's peanut butter eggs (24%), Cadbury Creme Eggs (16%), and Chocolate bunnies (13%)
  • Ever wonder what would happen if you microwave a Peep? You're not alone — almost 1 in 3 Americans have tried it.

Peeps: Love 'em or hate 'em?

Peeps were first introduced in 1953. Since then, these soft, sugary sweets have been found front and center in stores every year, ready for Easter baskets across the country.

Even if the typical shopper is no candy enthusiast, they've likely tried a Peep at least once. Only 2% of our survey respondents never tried a Peep, while only 3% say they have no clue what Peeps are.

Peeps are a divisive candy — people either love them or can't stand them. When asked to rate their feelings about Peeps on a scale of 1 to 10, 25% of people give Peeps a perfect "10" out of 10 rating. Conversely, 16% give them a "0" rating, corresponding to "Ick, I hate them!"


Which Peeps flavor does America like best?

Peeps lovers are faced with a dilemma when buying the treats — chicks or bunnies? As it turns out, bunnies beat out chicks as America's favorite Peeps shape — 57% prefer bunnies, while 43% prefer chicks.

A true Peeps lover knows Peeps don't just come in their original flavor. Peeps come in a variety of crazy flavors, from birthday cake to sour watermelon. For 2025 alone, Just Born introduced nine new flavors for Easter:

  • PEEPS® Chocolate Pudding Flavored Marshmallow Bunnies
  • PEEPS® Rice Krispies Treats® Flavored Marshmallow Chicks
  • PEEPS® Giant Bunny Pops
  • PEEPS® Delights™ Strawberry Flavored Marshmallow Chicks Dipped in Milk Chocolate
  • PEEPS® Egg Hunt
  • PEEPS® Jelly Beans
  • PEEPS® Breyers Cookies & Cream Flavored Marshmallow Chicks (exclusively at Wal-Mart)
  • PEEPS® Tropical Punch Flavored Marshmallow Bunnies (exclusively at Dollar Tree)
  • PEEPS® Cinnamon Churro Flavored Marshmallow Chicks (exclusively at Kroger Family of Stores)

So which flavors of Peeps are people most excited about?


Survey respondents were given seven different categories of Peeps flavors and, in each category, asked to choose the flavor they are most excited for. Then the winners of each category were pitted against one another. We asked each respondent to pick an ultimate winner from their category winners.

All told, nearly two dozen Peeps products were whittled down to the three that people like most. Taking the top spot is a variation on the original marshmallow treat, as Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Chicks were chosen as the most desired option by the highest percentage of respondents. Peeps Flavored Jelly Beans came in second, while Chocolate Pudding Bunnies captured the bronze.

Peeps in the wild (and in the microwave!)

While Peeps are obviously meant for eating, their role as a festive treat is not the only reason people love them. The marshmallows have carved out a niche as a source of experimentation for the young and the young at heart.

One of the most popular Peeps experiments is also one of the simplest. Our survey found that nearly 1/3 of people — 32% — have microwaved a Peep to see what happens.

If you've never microwaved a Peep, take a "peep" here at what happens when you do:

purple peep in microwave

America's other favorite Easter treats

Peeps are some of the most controversial holiday treats on the market. For those who aren't on the Peeps bandwagon, there are still plenty of other delicious Easter treats to choose from.


By far, the most popular Easter treat is Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs — 24% named the peanut butter-and-chocolate treats as their favorite Easter candy. Interestingly enough, Reese's eggs have been around almost as long as Peeps — they were introduced in 1967, 14 years after the invention of Peeps.

Following Reese's eggs are Cadbury Creme Eggs (16%) and chocolate bunnies (13%). Peeps were the sixth favorite, behind jelly beans and Easter-themed M&Ms. So while Peeps may be an iconic Easter treat, it might be a good idea to stock your Easter baskets with more top-ranked chocolate treats unless you are certain the basket recipient is a true Peeps fanatic.

How to save on your Easter goodies

Regardless of whether you're planning to include Peeps in your Easter festivities, there are ways to celebrate that fit any budget:

Methodology

FinanceBuzz surveyed 1,000 U.S. adults ages 18 or older, who comprise a nationally representative sample, on March 7, 2022. The list of new Peeps products for Easter 2025 was updated March 31, 2025.

Choose Your Cashback Category

4.4
info

Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards credit card

Annual Fee

$0

Benefits and Drawbacks
Card Details
Financebuzz logo

Thanks for subscribing!

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.