The One Group Dave Ramsey Says Should Not Do a Roth Conversion

Dave Ramsey argues that people who are already retired or within five years of retiring should generally skip a Roth conversion, pointing to the so-called five-year rule as his reasoning. While many investors follow that advice, a growing number of tax and retirement experts disagree with his conclusion, saying the decision depends on several personal financial factors.

Here's why the debate continues and what it could mean for your retirement planning.

Why Ramsey says near-retirees should avoid Roth conversions

Ramsey says a Roth conversion starts a five-year clock, leaving people who are already retired or close to retirement with less time to benefit from tax-free growth. He also believes many near-retirees don't have enough cash to pay the upfront tax bill without dipping into money they'll soon need.

As he puts it, "If you're going to turn right around and pull it back out within a few months or a few years, then that doesn't do any good."

How a Roth conversion works

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k), funded with pre-tax dollars, into a Roth IRA. You'll pay ordinary income tax on the amount converted in the year you make the move.

In return, future investment growth and qualified withdrawals become completely tax-free. Roth IRAs also have no required minimum distributions (RMDs) during the original owner's lifetime, giving retirees greater flexibility over their retirement income.

Why financial planners disagree with Ramsey

Certified Financial Planner Brandon Renfro argues that Ramsey misapplies the five-year rule. They note the rule primarily exists to prevent the 10% early-withdrawal penalty, which generally no longer applies once someone reaches age 59 1/2.

Because of that, many financial planners believe carefully planned Roth conversions can still benefit near-retirees, particularly when they expect higher tax rates later in retirement.

The real cost of following Ramsey's advice blindly

Critics argue that if everyone followed Ramsey's advice, only about 5% of people would realistically complete a Roth conversion. That's because most don't have enough cash outside their retirement accounts to pay the upfront tax bill.

For example, converting $50,000 from a $500,000 traditional IRA while in the 22% tax bracket creates an $11,000 tax bill, an amount many retirees struggle to pay from liquid savings.

Your future tax rate is the real deciding factor

Converting makes financial sense when you expect future tax rates to be higher than today's on the conversion amount.

Retirement author David McKnight argues that today's historically low tax rates may not last, noting the U.S. national debt is projected to reach $63 trillion by 2035. If taxes rise as a result, paying them now could prove cheaper than waiting until later in retirement.

Partial conversions could reduce the tax impact

A Roth conversion doesn't have to happen all at once. Many retirees spread conversions across several years to stay within lower federal tax brackets.

For example, in 2026, taxable income above $105,700 moves a single filer from the 22% to the 24% bracket. Converting smaller amounts each year could also help limit Medicare IRMAA surcharges two years later and reduce lifetime taxes.

RMDs are a major reason conversions stay popular

Traditional retirement accounts generally require RMDs starting at age 73, even if you don't need the money. Those mandatory withdrawals increase taxable income, and failing to take them carries a 25% excise tax, which can drop to 10% if you rectify within two years.

Roth IRAs don't require RMDs for the original owner, which is why many financial planners recommend gradual Roth conversions to help reduce future taxable withdrawals.

The gap years are when conversions are most powerful

Many financial planners consider the years between retirement and the start of RMDs, typically ages 62 to 72, the best time for Roth conversions because taxable income is often lower.

A retiree in the 12% tax bracket converting $50,000 pays $6,000 in tax. Waiting until RMDs push them into the 22% bracket raises the tax bill to $11,000, an extra $5,000.

The Roth conversion proposal remains personal, not universal

Ramsey's advice offers a simple rule of thumb, but Roth conversions are rarely one-size-fits-all. Income needs, filing status, investment balances, future RMDs, estate goals, and available cash all affect the outcome.

Two retirees with identical $500,000 traditional IRAs could make opposite decisions if one expects to stay in the 12% tax bracket while the other anticipates moving into the 22% bracket later.

Bottom line

Dave Ramsey believes people within five years of retirement should generally avoid Roth conversions, but many financial planners say there's no universal answer. The decision ultimately depends on your current and future tax brackets, whether you have cash available to cover the conversion tax, and how long the money can stay invested.

Running your numbers with a tax professional may help you avoid wasting money and ensure a comfortable retirement.

You May Also Like

$200 Bonus + Up to 5% Cash Back

Earn a $200 bonus after spending $500 on purchases in your first 3 months from account opening. Member FDIC

SPONSORED

23 Ways To Get Money Without Getting A Second Job

By FinanceBuzz Editors

How To Save Money on Car Insurance: 12 Ways to Lower Rates

By Elyssa Kirkham

10 Things Seniors Born Between 1941-1969 Could Take Advantage Of

By FinanceBuzz Editors

19 Dumbest Things Smart People Waste Money On

By Team FBZ

7 Moves If You Want to Stop Living Paycheck to Paycheck

By FinanceBuzz Editors

7 Clever Ways to Crush Your Debt

By FinanceBuzz Editors

Up To 5% Cash Back

Discover it^® Cash Back

Benefits Card Details

• Intro APR on purchases and balance transfers
• $0 annual fee
• Apply Now

• Get a 0% intro APR for 15 months on purchases and balance transfers; balance transfer fee applies. Then 17.49% to 26.49% Standard Variable Purchase APR applies, based on credit worthiness
• INTRO OFFER: Unlimited Cashback Match for all new cardmembers. Discover will automatically match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year! There’s no minimum spending or maximum rewards. You could turn $150 cash back into $300
• Earn 5% cash back on everyday purchases at different places you shop each quarter like grocery stores, restaurants, gas stations, and more, up to the quarterly maximum when you activate. Plus, earn unlimited 1% cash back on all other purchases
• Redeem cash back for any amount. No annual fee
• Terms and conditions apply

4.7

FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.

Apply Now

on Issuer's secure website

Rates and fees

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

INTRO OFFER: Unlimited Cashback Match for all new cardmembers. Discover will automatically match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year! There’s no minimum spending or maximum rewards. You could turn $150 cash back into $300

Annual Fee

$0

+ -

Why we like it

• The Discover it^® Cash Back is ideal for anyone who loves flexible rewards options.

• Cardholders can redeem their cash back for any amount.

• Earn 5% cash back on rotating bonus categories up to the quarterly maximum when you activate, along with 1% cash back on all purchases. Categories may include places like gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants, and more.

• Apply Now

---

Subscribe Today

Learn how to make an extra $200

Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.

or

Subscribe Now →

By submitting this form you agree to receive emails from FinanceBuzz and to the privacy policy and terms