12 Costco Bakery Hidden Gems That Even Experienced Shoppers Miss

Freshly baked desserts and sinfully sweet treats are among the top Costco shoppers' perks that members enjoy. People rave about Kirkland Signature's tiramisu cheesecake, the iconic tuxedo bar, and the ridiculously rich mammoth cupcakes (a.k.a. mini cakes).

While these are popular picks, some absolutely sumptuous ones go under the radar. So we decided to taste our way through Costco's bakery section and found a few hidden gems that deserve the spotlight.

Here's a list of a few bakery desserts you might be missing out on.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary depending on location and seasonality.

Price: $22.99

Costco recently brought back a fan favorite: the strawberry streusel cheesecake,

What do customers think? Redditor miifnkookeez posted, "I have zero regrets buying this…It reminds me of strawberry pretzel salad. It's light and fresh, not super rich like many cheesecakes."

This cheesecake combines a graham-style crust with a lighter cheesecake filling, fresh strawberries, and a crumbly streusel topping, giving it a texture closer to a fruit crisp than a traditional, dense New York-style cheesecake. 

At $22.99, it's priced in line with Costco's other specialty cheesecakes, making it an easy swap for shoppers who want something fruitier and less rich than the classic plain version.

Price: $17.99

While the classic features a sleek, sophisticated style, it isn't the only tuxedo in town. Check out the bakery section during your next pre-holiday shopping trip. You might find a dressed-up version of the beloved tuxedo cake. We spotted a springtime tuxedo cake topped with delicately piped frosting flowers.

Rich layers of dense chocolate cake, fluffy chocolate mousse, sweet white chocolate mousse, luxurious dark chocolate ganache, and chocolate cocoa nibs make it a fan favorite.

Because the decorated version is tied to seasonal releases rather than a year-round offering, its design and availability can change from one holiday or season to the next, so shoppers hoping to snag a specific look should ask bakery staff about the current rotation. At $17.99, it's priced the same as the classic tuxedo cake, so choosing the decorated version doesn't come with a premium.

Price: $9.99

Tired of plain chocolate chips? This tasty trio includes the OG of cookies, but that's not all. The 24-pack also features often-overlooked buttery double nut and oatmeal raisin recipes.

While shoppers enjoy all three varieties, they rave about the mouthwatering macadamia double nut sweets. Redditor Fayjaimike wrote, "Omg, these are ALWAYS the first row to disappear." And according to some Reddit users, some lucky customers scored a whole box of two dozen.

This variety pack splits its 24 cookies across three flavors, giving shoppers a mix rather than committing to a single type, which can be useful for households with different preferences. 

At $9.99 for two dozen cookies, the per-cookie cost works out to about 42 cents, similar to Costco's other bakery cookie packs and well below what a bakery or coffee shop typically charges for a single cookie.

Price: $10.99

You might miss these flaky, doughy sweets while you're searching for more conventional treats. You won't find these Eastern European cookies in many superstores or warehouse clubs' bakeries. But at Costco, this foodie find is a seasonal staple.

The 25-ounce variety pack with raspberry walnut, chocolate, and cream cheese filling cookies is a steal. For reference, fourteen ounces of Homestyle Kosher Rugelach costs $14.98 plus shipping from Zabar's (a famous NYC deli store online).

Rugelach are traditionally rolled pastries made from cream cheese dough wrapped around a sweet filling, and the variety pack's mix of raspberry walnut, chocolate, and cream cheese fillings gives shoppers several flavors in one box instead of committing to just one. 

Price: $9.99

These aren't the same plain cookies you get from the "snack" section. Costco's premium pick is packed with massive chunks of chocolate. And while almost $10 (or $0.42 each) may seem like a lot, consider the quality and quantity in comparison to similar options.

A pack of eight Pepperidge Farm Montauk Chocolate Chip Cookies costs $3.99 at Target ($0.50 each). Not only are they more expensive, but these brand-name treats are definitely not freshly baked.

Food reviewers have consistently ranked these among the best cookies in Costco's bakery lineup, praising the large chocolate chunks and buttery base as an upgrade from typical grocery-store chocolate chip cookies. 

Price: $17.99

This indulgent leche (milk) cake hides behind the tuxedo bar and often takes a backseat to its layered chocolate cousin. But this creamy, dreamy dessert deserves a spot in your cart, too.

Don't sleep on this bakery bargain if you find it. The caramel, three-milk (evaporated, condensed, and whole/cream) custard, and sponge cake aren't available year-round or in all regions.

Traditional tres leches cake gets its signature moist texture from soaking a light sponge cake in a mixture of three milks, and Costco's version adds a caramel element on top of that classic base. 

Price: $8.79

Costco showcases its store-brand bakery bargains. As a result, you may need to do a bit of sleuthing just to uncover a few non-Kirkland treats.

We scoured the sweets section and discovered these Meyer lemon bites. This seasonal product boasts a refreshingly sweet flavor, perfectly balanced with a hint of tart citrus taste.

Meyer lemons are naturally sweeter and less acidic than standard lemons, which typically gives desserts made with them a softer, more floral citrus flavor rather than the sharper tartness of a regular lemon bar. 

Bite-sized treats like these can also be a convenient option for parties or potlucks, since guests can grab one without needing to cut and serve individual slices.

Price: $18.99

The sudden debut of this new addition to Costco's family of bar cakes surprised shoppersby surprise —in a good way. Cream cheese icing, raisins, toasted walnuts, pineapple, and (of course) carrots make this delicious dessert a pleasant alternative to overly indulgent chocolate and buttercream confections.

This bar cake joins Costco's existing lineup of sheet-style desserts like the tuxedo bar and tres leches bar, cut into individual squares rather than sold as a whole round cake, making it easier to serve a crowd without slicing a full cake. 

The combination of raisins, walnuts, and pineapple is a classic addition to carrot cake recipes, adding texture and natural sweetness alongside the carrots themselves. 

At $18.99, it's priced similarly to Costco's other bar cakes, giving carrot cake fans a lighter option than the chocolate-heavy desserts that dominate the rest of the bakery case.

Price: $12.99

Costco shoppers can't stop talking about the new apple berry berry pie ($15.99), which recently hit the bakery section's shelves.

The delicious mix of fruit has earned praise, and for good reason. But for $3 less, you can score the classic apples-only version. So if you're a pie purist, skip the latest trend and nab the four-plus-pound plain pick.

Both pies weigh close to 4.5 to 5 pounds and span about 12 inches, large enough to serve 8 to 16 people depending on slice size, making either one a practical dessert for a gathering rather than a single household. 

The classic apple version uses apples, a flaky double crust, and warm spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, and Costco has occasionally sold a version made with organic apples specifically, so shoppers who care about that distinction should check the label before buying.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price: $6.99

Sometimes, less is more. Don't let the fancy lemon icing and blueberry goodness of Costco's other popular loaf distract you from this overlooked item. The all-butter pound cake is rich, moist, and absolutely indulgent in the best way possible.

Pound cake gets its name from the traditional recipe of using a pound each of butter, sugar, flour, and eggs, and an "all-butter" version like this one skips shortening or oil substitutes in favor of butter alone, which tends to give it a denser crumb and richer flavor than lighter cake varieties. 

Because it isn't as sweet or decorated as many of Costco's other bakery items, it works well on its own with coffee or tea, or as a base for a more elaborate dessert topped with fresh berries, whipped cream, or a fruit compote.

Price: $17.99

The latest viral cheesecake trends and artistically decorated party cakes caught your eye. But what about this unadorned option? It may not have fancy frosting flowers, chocolate shavings, or a caramel crust. And that's okay. This 10-inch round hidden gem's chocolate cake-and-mousse combo is everything you need and more.

A cake-and-mousse combination like this typically layers a moist chocolate cake with a lighter, airier chocolate mousse filling, giving it a different texture than a dense fudge cake while still delivering strong chocolate flavor throughout. 

Because it skips elaborate decoration, it can be a practical choice for a simple birthday or celebration where you want a reliably good dessert without paying extra for fondant work or piped details. 

At $17.99 for a 10-inch cake, it's priced the same as Costco's decorated tuxedo and tres leches bar cakes, so the simpler presentation lets you get a comparable amount of dessert for the same cost.

Price: $9.99

You might find a very special springtime surprise hidden away behind tubs of chocolate chip mini cookies and containers of croissants. These sweet, buttery treats have a soft, almost spongy texture and a flavor you'll savor.

Sugar cookies like these are typically made from a simple butter-based dough, and the springtime framing suggests this is a seasonal or limited-run item rather than a year-round bakery staple, so it may only appear during certain times of year. 

At $9.99, the price matches Costco's other bakery cookie packs, and the soft, spongy texture described here sets it apart from crisper, snap-style sugar cookies sold at most grocery store bakeries. 

Because seasonal bakery items can rotate in and out with little notice, shoppers who spot them are often better off buying on sight rather than planning a return trip, since there's no guarantee they'll still be available later.

From a seasonally decorated version of the classic tuxedo cake to chocolate chunk cookies, you don't need a special occasion to indulge in these delicious treats.

And the bargains don't stop here. Save money on groceries that pair perfectly with your favorite desserts. Snag Kirkland Signature's vanilla ice cream or try the store-brand generic heavy whipped cream.

Because several items on this list are seasonal or region-specific, it's worth checking Costco's app or asking bakery staff about current stock before making a special trip for a single item. 

Pairing these desserts with pantry staples like Kirkland Signature's vanilla ice cream or heavy whipping cream is also an easy way to round out a dessert spread without making a separate trip to another store.