New Study Says Americans Are Being Overcharged for Insurance - 5 Effective Strategies to Lower Your Bill

A recent analysis from the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator estimates that U.S. consumers are overpaying about $150 billion each year for home, auto, and business insurance. At the same time, 71% of homeowners say their insurance costs have risen recently, and 42% report that those increases were "a lot," underscoring how widespread the problem has become.

Whether you're already feeling the pinch or worried your rates could jump next, there are practical steps you can take to bring your premiums down. In many cases, these strategies can help cope with increasing bills even in a tight economy.

How insurers are overcharging

The Vanderbilt data looked at insurance premiums collected versus claims paid. What it showed is that insurers only pay out about 62 cents for every dollar of premiums collected, down from around 80 cents in the 80s and 90s.

This means more of your money is going to expenses, profit, or cash reserves instead of paying for insurance claims. The gap, called a "loss ratio," amounts to $150 billion in money that consumers pay but don't see a return from. If the ratio were more in line with previous decades, a homeowner could pay hundreds less for the same $2,500 policy.

Additional hidden drivers of cost

Insurers are also experiencing true risk factors that drive up the cost of insurance, even without the loss ratio issue mentioned before. These include:

• Climate risk repricing
• Higher reinsurance costs
• Litigation trends
• Loyalty penalties
• Inflation in repair/rebuild costs
• More frequent and severe weather events
• Regulatory or market changes
• Risk modeling that heavily weighs certain data points (like location and credit)

Anything that causes insurers to spend more, including their own insurance (called "reinsurance"), usually gets passed along to the consumer as higher premiums or less coverage for the same price. These next steps can help you save, even as prices rise.

Manage your property's risk profile

In areas where wildfires, hurricanes, floods, or other climate risks are high, premiums are typically higher. While you can't control the weather, you can control how prepared you are to meet disaster.

Installing fire-resistant roofing or storm-proof windows may limit the damage caused when bad weather does strike. Your insurer may reward your proactive efforts with a discount, and you should always ask which measures they reward the most.

At a minimum, it may keep them from dropping you altogether the next time there's a climate event.

Compare prices

Two factors for rising rates (reinsurance costs and loyalty penalties) can be overcome by simply shopping around. Even if you really like your insurer and have no reason to leave, you could save hundreds with another company.

Some insurers charge long-term customers higher premiums because they assume you won't shop around, then give new customers the best rates. By looking at other companies, you avoid this trap and get the chance to discover companies that don't pass along as much of their reinsurance cost to their customers.

Look at multiple carriers each year. If you don't want to switch, at least ask your current insurer if they can meet a competitor's offer.

Navigate litigation trends wisely

More frequent or complex lawsuits over claims increase the insurer's legal costs. This often shows up as higher premiums for its customers.

Do your part to avoid being seen as a high litigation risk by documenting any property or auto damage with photos, videos, and timelines as soon as the damage occurs. Stay within the normal claims process and use existing internal appeals before jumping to sue the other party (or your insurer), unless advised by an attorney.

While you shouldn't give up any rights given to you in the policy, you should also be familiar with how systemic litigation trends contribute to higher costs for everyone.

Balance coverage, deductibles, and protection

If you want to keep your insurer but can't swing the high cost of premiums, you can make changes to your policy. Prices are directly tied to how much coverage you carry and your deductible. Scaling back on coverage and increasing your deductible usually reduces the monthly bill.

Just be sure you don't leave yourself vulnerable to costs you can't cover if you do need to file a claim. Getting rid of duplicate roadside assistance or rental car coverage is one thing; doubling your deductible too high is another. You should have enough in an emergency fund to cover any deductible and get you back on track quickly.

Use bundling and good credit to your advantage

You've already seen the ads to combine home and auto, which can help you save 5% to 25%. This only works if it truly fits your needs, however, so don't feel pressure to move policies to an insurer that doesn't make sense for you.

Since many states allow credit-based insurance scores (similar to credit scores) to influence pricing, you could also see relief if you're on top of your finances. It's not available to everyone, but raising your score can lower rates over time. Combining plans becomes an extra win for those considered a low credit risk.

Bottom line

Americans are overcharged for insurance, and the issue doesn't seem to be resolving soon. Most can't do without their policies, but they can adjust them. Shopping around for a new insurance policy, tweaking coverage, and reducing risk can help get costs within budget.

Set aside time once a year to review every policy you carry and walk through the strategies outlined above. Staying proactive and diligent is an ongoing commitment, not a one-and-done task — but the payoff shows up directly in your wallet.

You May Also Like

23 Ways To Get Money Without Getting A Second Job

By FinanceBuzz Editors

How To Save Money on Car Insurance: 12 Ways to Lower Rates

By Elyssa Kirkham

10 Things Seniors Born Between 1941-1969 Could Take Advantage Of

By FinanceBuzz Editors

19 Dumbest Things Smart People Waste Money On

By Team FBZ

7 Moves If You Want to Stop Living Paycheck to Paycheck

By FinanceBuzz Editors

7 Clever Ways to Crush Your Debt

By FinanceBuzz Editors

Up To 5% Cash Back

Discover it^® Cash Back

Benefits Card Details

• Intro APR on purchases and balance transfers
• $0 annual fee
• Apply Now

• Get a 0% intro APR for 15 months on purchases and balance transfers; balance transfer fee applies. Then 17.49% to 26.49% Standard Variable Purchase APR applies, based on credit worthiness
• INTRO OFFER: Unlimited Cashback Match for all new cardmembers. Discover will automatically match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year! There’s no minimum spending or maximum rewards. You could turn $150 cash back into $300
• Earn 5% cash back on everyday purchases at different places you shop each quarter like grocery stores, restaurants, gas stations, and more, up to the quarterly maximum when you activate. Plus, earn unlimited 1% cash back on all other purchases
• Redeem cash back for any amount. No annual fee
• Terms and conditions apply

4.7

FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.

Apply Now

on Issuer's secure website

Rates and fees

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

INTRO OFFER: Unlimited Cashback Match for all new cardmembers. Discover will automatically match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year! There’s no minimum spending or maximum rewards. You could turn $150 cash back into $300

Annual Fee

$0

+ -

Why we like it

• The Discover it^® Cash Back is ideal for anyone who loves flexible rewards options.

• Cardholders can redeem their cash back for any amount.

• Earn 5% cash back on rotating bonus categories up to the quarterly maximum when you activate, along with 1% cash back on all purchases. Categories may include places like gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants, and more.

• Apply Now

---

Subscribe Today

Learn how to make an extra $200

Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.

or

Subscribe Now →

By submitting this form you agree to receive emails from FinanceBuzz and to the privacy policy and terms