Dave Ramsey built his reputation by telling people to get out of debt and build wealth with simple, steady habits. Millions of people credit his advice for turning their finances around.
But some financial advisors say a few of his rules work differently once you are living off your savings instead of adding to them. Here are five of the most debated rules, plus what advisors suggest thinking about instead.
Now Available: The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income
Many successful investors eventually reach the same moment. The saving is done, the portfolio is built, and the question quietly changes from how much can I grow this to how much can I take out? Get that second question wrong and decades of good investing can come apart in a handful of years.
That is exactly what The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income helps answer.1 <p class="">Investing in securities involves a risk of loss. Past performance is never a guarantee of future returns. Investing in foreign stock markets involves additional risks, such as the risk of currency fluctuations. Guides are provided by Fisher Investments. The publisher may be compensated when readers request a guide.</p> It covers what your retirement could actually cost, which income sources are worth using, and the withdrawal math that decides whether the money lasts. It is free today from Fisher Investments. Read More Here ›
His 8% withdrawal rule could drain your savings faster than you think
What this means for you: the size of your yearly withdrawal is the single biggest lever in your retirement plan, and 8% is a lot to pull out.
On a November 2023 episode of his call-in show, Ramsey told a caller with a $1.5 million portfolio that retirees can take out 8% of their savings every year and never touch the principal, according to write-ups of the broadcast. His math was simple: a 12% average yearly return minus 4% inflation leaves 8% to spend. He described the result as money that never runs out.
Advisors say the flaw is treating an average return like a guaranteed one. Markets don't hand you the same return every year. Some years are great, and some are ugly, and the order matters a lot once you are pulling money out.
Planners call this sequence-of-returns risk, which is just a fancy way of saying that a bad stretch early in retirement can do lasting damage. You sell shares to cover bills while prices are low, so there is less money left to bounce back when the market recovers.
Fidelity shows how this works with two made-up portfolios. Each starts with the same amount, follows the same withdrawal schedule, and earns the same returns over 25 years, just in opposite order. The one that hits losses first is completely out of money by year 21. The one that gets the good years first ends up with more than double its starting balance two decades later.
Vanguard's retirement income research points to a much lower starting point. It suggests pulling roughly 3.5% to 4% of savings a year to cover what is left after Social Security and other steady income, a pace it says can support a retirement of 30 years or more. That is about half of what Ramsey floated. A financial advisor can help set a withdrawal plan around a specific portfolio, spending level, and health picture.
Staying fully invested in stocks ignores how retirees actually use their money
What this means for you: if everything is in stocks, a down market can force you to sell at a bad time just to pay bills.
Ramsey Solutions says on its site that retirees should keep growth stock mutual funds in their portfolios even after they stop working, because that money can keep growing and a too-cautious mix can lose ground to inflation, as reported by TheStreet.
Inflation is a real worry for retirees on a fixed income. But advisors generally say an all-stock mix creates a different problem once withdrawals start: there is no safer pile to pull from when stocks are down, so a slump turns into locked-in losses.
That is why many planners suggest holding some bonds or cash once you begin taking money out, so a bad year doesn't force a sale. For context on how households actually invest, Vanguard's 2025 retirement outlook research estimates that people with access to a workplace retirement plan hold about 40% of their money in stocks and 30% in cash, a very different mix from all stocks.
The right balance depends on income needs, other assets, and comfort with risk, which is where an advisor can help.
Picking actively managed funds over index funds is a tough bet to win
What this means for you: higher fund fees come out of your returns every single year, win or lose.
Ramsey has long favored actively managed mutual funds, where a manager picks investments and tries to beat the market, over low-cost index funds that simply track a market benchmark. In one call-in exchange, a listener argued that index fund investors could end up with far more money by retirement because the fees are lower. Ramsey pushed back hard, pointing to his decades in the business and the money his own fund picks have made him.
The track record is not kind to that position. S&P Dow Jones Indices tracks how active funds stack up against their benchmarks in its SPIVA scorecard. For the five years that ended June 30, 2025, 88% of U.S. stock funds trailed their benchmark index. Fees come out every year, which makes it hard for a manager to stay ahead over long stretches.
Many advisors suggest low-cost index funds for at least part of a retirement portfolio for exactly that reason. It doesn't mean every active fund loses, but the odds in that data favor the index.
Released: The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income
Most people spend their entire working lives focusing on one thing: growing a pile of money. Then they retire and discover the skill they actually need is close to the opposite. Turning that pile into steady income, year after year, through good markets and bad, without ever running out. It may be the least discussed and most consequential transition in personal finance, and plenty of otherwise careful investors walk into it with no real plan.
That is exactly what The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income helps answer.1 <p class="">Investing in securities involves a risk of loss. Past performance is never a guarantee of future returns. Investing in foreign stock markets involves additional risks, such as the risk of currency fluctuations. Guides are provided by Fisher Investments. The publisher may be compensated when readers request a guide.</p> It is a free guide from Fisher Investments covering what your retirement will really cost, where the cash flow should come from, and how much you can safely withdraw each year. Learn More Here ›
Broadly dismissing annuities ignores a tool some retirees find useful
What this means for you: one narrow type of annuity can cover your must-pay bills for life, even though many others are expensive.
Ramsey has generally told callers to steer clear of annuities, often calling them bad investments with high fees. Plenty of advisors agree that many annuities, especially variable ones with layers of fees, are a poor fit for most people. Others say that broad caution misses one use: income annuities that are meant to cover basic, recurring bills for life.
An annuity is a contract with an insurance company, according to the SEC's investor education site. You hand over a lump sum or a series of payments, and the insurer sends you income either right away or starting later. Some contracts add a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, which lets you take out a set percentage each year for life even if the account value drops to zero.
Advisors who support limited use typically frame it as a way to lock in the housing and grocery money, leaving the rest of the portfolio free to grow. Costs vary a lot. The SEC notes that a contract's charge for cashing out early can start as high as 7% in the first year and fall by one percentage point a year after that. Anyone considering an annuity should read the contract terms closely or talk it through with an advisor first.
Paying off the mortgage early can trigger a costly tax bill in retirement
What this means for you: the payoff money usually comes out of a pre-tax account, and that withdrawal counts as income.
Ramsey is famous for telling people to kill the mortgage as fast as possible, retirement included. On the surface, it adds up: no mortgage payment means lower monthly bills.
Advisors point out a catch that hits retirees specifically if they use retirement savings to pay off the mortgage. If the cash to wipe out a loan comes from a traditional 401(k) or IRA, some or all of that money may not have been taxed yet.
Pull out a big lump sum, and the taxable portion counts as income that year, which can push you into a higher tax bracket. If you are under age 59 1/2, there is also an extra 10% tax on early withdrawals, and the IRS list of exceptions does not include paying off a mortgage.
Advisors generally suggest weighing the peace of mind of being debt-free against that tax bill. An advisor or tax pro can run the numbers for a specific situation.
Where advisors agree with Ramsey
Despite the pushback, many advisors give Ramsey credit for one core idea: staying out of debt matters at any age. His push to build an emergency fund and avoid high-interest debt is still solid for most households, retirees included.
The disconnect comes down to audience. His rules were largely built for younger, working people who are paying off debt and saving over decades. Retirees face different risks, including bad timing in the market, living longer than planned, and health costs.
Retirement News: Almost 80% of Americans fear a retirement age increase — here’s the real reason why
Bottom line
Ramsey's rules have helped a lot of people get out of debt and start saving, and his message about avoiding debt still holds up after you stop working. But several of his retirement-specific tactics, including the 8% withdrawal idea, all-stock portfolios, and his broad caution on annuities, clash with what research from Fidelity, Vanguard, and S&P Dow Jones Indices shows.
Retirement income planning leans heavily on your own bills, health, other income, and comfort with risk. Instead of following any one personality's rule across the board, it may help to talk with a fee-only financial advisor who can build a plan around your actual numbers.
More from FinanceBuzz:
- Retire like the rich: 14 ways you could build wealth in your 50s.
- Find out if you could pay less for car insurance in just a few clicks.
- Make these 7 savvy moves when you have $1,000 in the bank.
- 14 moves seniors could benefit from but often forget about.
Add Us On Google